climatechangescams?

“Scam” is the question here, not a finding. A charge is shown as a charge, and people charged are presumed innocent. Motive, intent and coordination stay marked ⚠. Each card says who held the pen and who paid.

01

Deadlines that came and went

The end was due.
The morning came anyway.

Each warning below is quoted word for word, with its date. Under each one: what the speaker, or the people who stand by it, said it meant. Set them next to today and decide.

Associated Press · June 29, 1989

A senior UN environment official: “entire nations could be wiped off the face of the Earth by rising sea levels if the global warming trend is not reversed by the year 2000.”

What it meant, per a later review: the UN/EPA papers behind the story described sea-level scenarios over the coming century, not by 2000. The official, Noel Brown, was a diplomat, not a climate scientist, and his view was not the consensus then.

AP archive · Snopes review, Sept 20, 2019

Pen
Noel Brown, UNEP’s New York office, to an AP reporter.
Paid
UNEP: member governments.

Nobel lecture, Oslo · December 10, 2007

Al Gore on the North Polar ice cap: “One study estimated that it could be completely gone during summer in less than 22 years. Another new study… warns it could happen in as little as 7 years. Seven years from now.”

In his framing: both numbers were credited to other researchers’ studies, not to him. The September ice record is public: check each year’s minimum at NSIDC.

NobelPrize.org, full lecture text

Pen
Gore, citing two studies.
Paid
The stage and the prize: the Nobel Foundation.

UN climate summit, Copenhagen · December 2009

Gore again: “a 75 percent chance that the entire north polar ice cap, during the summer months, could be completely ice-free within five to seven years.”

The scientist he named answered: “It’s unclear to me how this figure was arrived at. I would never try to estimate likelihood at anything as exact as this.” — Wieslaw Maslowski. Gore’s office said the 75% was a “ballpark figure” from an earlier conversation.

UPI, Dec 15, 2009, citing The Times of London

Pen
Gore on stage; the scientist and Gore’s office, quoted by The Times.
Paid
Gore spoke for himself. Maslowski’s research: the U.S. Naval Postgraduate School, public money.

IPCC 1.5°C report, Incheon · October 8, 2018

To hold warming to 1.5°C, net CO₂ emissions would need to fall about 45% from 2010 levels by 2030, reaching “net zero” around 2050.

How the panel frames it: a pathway with target years, approved by governments. It does not name 2030 as an end of the world. The “12 years” headlines counted forward from this report.

IPCC press release, Oct 8, 2018 · Inverse, on where “12 years” came from

Pen
Report authors; summary approved line by line by governments.
Paid
Member governments, through the IPCC Trust Fund.

MLK Now, New York · January 21, 2019

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez: “Millennials and Gen Z and all these folks that come after us are looking up, and we’re like, ‘The world is going to end in 12 years if we don’t address climate change, and your biggest issue is how are we gonna pay for it?’”

Her own explanation, May 12, 2019: “This is a technique of the GOP, to take dry humor + sarcasm literally and ‘fact check’ it. Like the ‘world ending in 12 years’ thing, you’d have to have the social intelligence of a sea sponge to think it’s literal.”

USA Today, Jan 22, 2019 · HuffPost, with her post, May 12, 2019

Pen
She did, on stage and on X.
Paid
Her salary: taxpayers. ⚠ Event funding not checked here.

Sit with it

  • When a date passes, does the warning get retired — or renamed?
  • If a line was “humor” or a “ballpark,” who goes back and tells the people who believed it?
  • Who keeps the list of forecasts that came true, and the ones that didn’t?
02

Rising seas & seaside homes

The seas are rising.
Why buy on the shore?

First the measured water. Then the warnings. Then the choices of some of the people who gave the warnings — and what they said when asked. What do their choices say? You decide.

The measured water

NOAA tide gauge, The Battery, New York · 1856–2025

The oldest U.S. tide record: about 2.95 mm a year — roughly one foot per century.

NOAA Tides & Currents, sea level trends table

Pen
NOAA, a federal agency.
Paid
Taxpayers.

“An Inconvenient Truth” · UK High Court, October 10, 2007

The film warned of seas up to 20 feet higher. A judge reviewing it for schools called the “in the near future” framing “distinctly alarmist”: that much melt would take millennia. The film could still be shown, with guidance.

Dimmock v Secretary of State [2007] EWHC 2288 · BBC, Oct 11, 2007

Pen
Mr Justice Burton.
Paid
The case: a parent’s challenge (⚠ its backers not checked here) and the UK government’s defense.

The shore, the jets — and their own answers

St. Paul, Minnesota · June 3, 2008 → Martha’s Vineyard · December 4, 2019

Barack Obama, 2008: “this was the moment when the rise of the oceans began to slow and our planet began to heal.” In 2019 his family’s trust bought a 29-acre waterfront estate on Martha’s Vineyard for $11.75 million.

His side: ⚠ No public response from him to the seaside-home question was found in this search.

NPR transcript, 2008 · Vineyard Gazette, Dec 4, 2019 · Snopes

Pen
His speech; the county deed registry.
Paid
The buyer’s trust.

Montecito, California · April 2010

Al and Tipper Gore bought an ocean-view villa — five bedrooms, nine baths, six fireplaces — for $8,875,000.

Their side: the couple said only that they bought it “following a process of long and careful consideration.”

Los Angeles Times, May 8, 2010 · CBS News

Pen
Real-estate sources, via the press.
Paid
The Gores.

Davos · May 2022 (study January 2023)

During World Economic Forum week, 1,040 private-jet flights came and went at airports serving Davos — about half attributed to the forum.

Greenpeace / CE Delft · The Guardian, Jan 13, 2023

Pen
CE Delft, commissioned by Greenpeace, an advocacy group.
Paid
Greenpeace donors. The flights: the travelers.

Reykjavík · October 2019 (reported February 2021)

Asked if a private jet was “an environmental way to travel,” John Kerry, later U.S. climate envoy: “If you offset your carbon, it’s the only choice for somebody like me who is traveling the world to win this battle.”

Later: his family’s Gulfstream was sold in August 2022. His office: “Secretary Kerry travels commercially in his role as Special Presidential Envoy for Climate.”

Fox News, Feb 2021 · Washington Examiner, Feb 15, 2023

Pen
An Icelandic reporter’s recording; his spokeswoman.
Paid
The jet: his wife’s family company, Flying Squirrel LLC.

July–August 2022

A marketing firm’s ranking estimated Taylor Swift’s jet made 170 flights in 2022’s first seven months, about 8,293 tonnes of CO₂.

Her side: a spokesperson said the jet “is loaned out regularly to other individuals” and that pinning most or all trips on her was “blatantly incorrect.”

The Guardian, Aug 2, 2022

Pen
Yard, a UK marketing agency, using public flight trackers.
Paid
Yard. ⚠ Who was aboard each flight is not shown by the data.

Sit with it

  • The water is measured in millimetres a year. Which number were you told — the gauge, or the 20 feet?
  • If someone warns of rising seas and buys on the shore, does that tell you about the sea — or about the warning? ⚠ Only they can say what they believe.
  • Is an offset a cleaner flight, or a receipt?
03

How carbon works

Plant food
or pollutant?

Four in every ten thousand molecules of air are CO₂. Plants eat it. Growers pump more of it into greenhouses. The mainstream view says it also traps heat. Here is each side in its own words, with the numbers. Weigh them.

Ontario Ministry of Agriculture · grower factsheet

Raising greenhouse CO₂ to about 1,000 ppm lifts photosynthesis in most crops by about 50%. Growers are advised to enrich to 1,000 ppm on sunny days.

Ontario, “Supplemental carbon dioxide in greenhouses”

Pen
Provincial crop specialists.
Paid
Ontario taxpayers.

Nature Climate Change · April 25, 2016

Satellites show 25–50% of the world’s vegetated land grew greener from 1982 to 2009. Models credit about 70% of that to CO₂ fertilisation.

Zhu et al., “Greening of the Earth and its drivers” · BBC

Pen
An international team led from Peking University and Boston University.
Paid
Public science agencies, including NASA. ⚠ Full grant list not checked here.

Nature · May 7, 2014 · the other side of “plant food”

Wheat grown at 546–586 ppm had about 9% less zinc and 5% less iron; rice lost about 8% of its protein.

Myers et al., “Increasing CO₂ threatens human nutrition”

Pen
A Harvard-led analysis of open-field CO₂ trials in Japan, Australia and the U.S.
Paid
⚠ Funders listed in the paper; not checked here.
02468280420560840112014002025: 427 ppmdoubled: 3.7 W/m²greenhouse growers: ~1,000 ppmCO₂ in the air (parts per million)extra push, W/m² (vs. 280 ppm)
Each added ppm traps less extra heat than the one before — the effect is logarithmic. A doubling from 280 to 560 ppm adds about 3.7 watts per square metre. Formula: ΔF = 5.35 × ln(C/280), from Myhre et al., 1998, the figure the IPCC uses. Pen: Norwegian and British researchers. Paid: public research councils.

The mainstream view · IPCC, August 9, 2021

“It is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land.”
The panel’s best estimate: doubling CO₂ warms Earth about 3°C over time, likely 2.5–4°C, because water vapour and ice changes amplify the 3.7 W/m² push. AR6 WG1 Summary for Policymakers. Pen: authors, approved by governments.

The dissenting view · CO2 Coalition, May 5, 2023

“…strong evidence that there is no climate crisis and that increasing CO₂ concentrations will benefit the world.”
William Happer, Princeton physicist emeritus and the group’s board chair, speaking of John Clauser’s work in its release. The same release argues clouds act as a thermostat that dwarfs CO₂’s push. ⚠ The group’s funders not checked here.

Sit with it

  • If growers pay to raise CO₂ to 1,000 ppm, what does “pollutant” mean?
  • If each added ppm traps less heat than the last, why do the big forecasts still differ — and who decides which feedbacks count?
  • Greener fields, thinner nutrients: which one makes the headline?
04

Solar panels & wind turbines

Who profits
from the panels?

Follow a panel and a blade from the mine to the landfill. Who pays at each step, who gets paid, and who answers for it?

The tax credit · Aug 2022 → July 4, 2025

Federal tax credits paid part of the bill for new wind and solar. A 2025 law sets an end: projects that start construction after July 4, 2026 must be in service by the end of 2027 to claim them.

IRS Notice 2025-42 · McGuireWoods summary, July 2025

Pen
Congress, then the IRS.
Paid
Taxpayers. Credits go to the project owners and investors who file for them.

International Energy Agency · July 2022

China’s share of every stage of solar panel making — polysilicon, ingots, wafers, cells, modules — is more than 80%.

IEA, Solar PV Global Supply Chains

Pen
IEA analysts.
Paid
IEA member governments.

May 2021 · June 21, 2022

A university report found Xinjiang made about 45% of the world’s solar-grade polysilicon, and that all four producers there took part in state labour-transfer programmes or bought from firms that did. Since June 21, 2022, U.S. law presumes Xinjiang goods are made with forced labour unless importers prove otherwise.

Their own words: China’s foreign ministry called the law “an escalation of US suppression on China under the pretext of human rights” (June 21, 2022). The U.S. solar trade group urged members to move supply chains out of Xinjiang (Dec 10, 2020).

Sheffield Hallam, “In Broad Daylight” · CBP, UFLPA · PRC embassy · SEIA

Pen
University researchers; Congress and U.S. Customs; China’s government; the industry.
Paid
⚠ Report funding not checked here. Detained shipments: importers carry the cost.

IRENA & IEA-PVPS · June 20, 2016

Worn-out solar panels could add up to 78 million tonnes of waste worldwide by 2050, mostly glass.

The same report’s answer: if fully recovered, the materials could be worth more than $15 billion — enough for 2 billion new panels. In most countries, panels are still classed as “general waste.”

IRENA press release · full report

Pen
IRENA, an agency that promotes renewable energy.
Paid
Its member governments.

Casper, Wyoming · February 5, 2020

A city landfill had taken in 870 retired turbine blades, cut into sections and buried, because the fiberglass is hard to crush, recycle or reuse.

The industry’s answer: blades can be ground into cement-kiln feedstock, and recyclable blades are in development (American Clean Power). Europe’s wind trade group called for a ban on landfilling blades by 2025 (June 2021).

Bloomberg · ACP fact sheet · WindEurope

Pen
Journalists; then the trade groups.
Paid
Landfill fees: the wind operators. Trade groups: member companies.

U.S. District Court, Wyoming · April 2022

A NextEra subsidiary pleaded guilty to killing eagles at its wind farms — at least 150 bald and golden eagles since 2012 — and paid more than $8 million in fines and restitution.

U.S. Department of Justice · Reuters, Apr 7, 2022

Pen
Federal prosecutors; the company’s own plea.
Paid
ESI Energy paid; up to $27 million more for an eagle-protection plan.

USDA Economic Research Service · 2024

About 70% of solar farms and over 90% of wind turbines built in rural America sit on farm or ranch land. Together they covered about 424,000 acres in 2020 — roughly 0.05% of U.S. farmland.

USDA ERS, Amber Waves, Sept 2024 · full report

Pen
USDA economists.
Paid
Taxpayers. Landowners receive the lease payments.

International Energy Agency · May 2021

An onshore wind plant needs nine times more mineral resources than a gas-fired plant of the same capacity.

IEA, The Role of Critical Minerals in Clean Energy Transitions

Pen
IEA analysts.
Paid
IEA member governments. The mines: ⚠ where, and under whose labour rules, not traced here.

FERC & NERC · November 2021

In the February 2021 Texas freeze, 1,045 power units failed or cut back. 58% burned natural gas; 27% were wind turbines, mostly from ice on the blades.

FERC–NERC final report

Pen
Federal regulators and the grid-reliability body.
Paid
Ratepayers and taxpayers.

Sit with it

  • If a panel is clean on the roof, who counts the mine, the factory and the landfill?
  • When a credit ends, does the industry stand on its own — or was the credit the business?
  • Who decides which deaths count: an eagle under a blade, or a bird in a warming world?
05

The energy it takes to make energy

How much energy does it
cost to make energy?

Every power source spends energy before it gives any back: mining, factories, steel, concrete, fuel, and storage for when the wind stops. Two different questions follow. How much energy comes back? And what does it cost in dollars?

How to read this

  • EROI (“energy return on investment”) = how many units of energy you get back for every 1 unit spent building, fueling and running a power source. Like a return on investment, but counted in energy, not dollars.
  • Bigger bar = more energy back. “75” means about 75 units back for every 1 put in. It is not a cost.
  • The red line at 7: the study says a modern economy needs about 7 back for 1 in. Below it, too much energy goes into making energy. The dotted line at 3: another researcher’s bare minimum for a fuel to be useful at all.
  • Dark vs. light bars: wind and sun come and go. Dark = with storage added so the power is steady; light = without storage.

Question 1: how much energy comes back?

Swipe sideways to see the whole chart →

Energy back for every 1 unit put in (higher = more energy back)Steady source, or wind/solar with storage addedWind/solar without storage020406080Nuclear75 back for 1 inHydro (river)35 back for 1 inCoal30 back for 1 inGas28 back for 1 inSolar thermal (desert)9 with storage · 21 withoutWind (Germany)3.9 with storage · 16 withoutSolar panels (Germany)1.6 with storage · 3.9 without│ red line at 7 = the study’s line for a modern economy┊ dotted at 3 = bare minimum (Hall)73
One study: Weißbach et al., Energy, April 2013. Wind and solar figures use German sun and wind. This chart measures energy, not money. Pen: physicists at German research institutes. ⚠ Funding not checked here.

Why another study gets a different number for solar

Raugei et al. · Energy Policy · 2017

A different team looked at solar panels in Switzerland: about 9–10 back for 1 in, or 7–8 when services like insurance and management are counted too. The first study said 1.6–3.9 for German solar.

Why the gap? How much sun the site gets. Newer, more efficient panels and factories. What gets counted in the “energy in.” And storage: the 1.6 includes storage; the 9–10 does not.

Raugei et al., “ERoEI for photovoltaic solar systems in regions of moderate insolation: a comprehensive response” (paraphrased) — a reply to an earlier study that put Swiss solar below 1.

Pen
University and lab researchers in Europe and the U.S.
Paid
⚠ Funding not checked here.

Hall, Lambert & Balogh · Energy Policy · 2014

A fuel needs to return at least about 3 units for every 1 put in just to be minimally useful to society — the dotted line on the chart.

Read it this way: 3 is a floor, not a goal. ⚠ Where the right line sits — 3, 7 or higher — is still argued.

Hall, Lambert & Balogh, “EROI of different fuels and the implications for society” (paraphrased)

Pen
Charles Hall, a pioneer of EROI research, and colleagues.
Paid
⚠ Funding not checked here.

Question 2 — a different question: what does it cost in dollars?

Notice the flip. Nuclear gives the most energy back on the chart above — and has the highest dollar cost to build below. Wind and solar are the cheapest to build per megawatt-hour, before paying for backup when the wind drops or the sun sets. Lazard prices that backup (“firming”) separately; with it, they cost more.
Dollars per megawatt-hour (1,000 kilowatt-hours — roughly a month of power for a typical U.S. home), new U.S. plants, without subsidies. “With backup” = Lazard’s cost of firming wind and solar in five U.S. grid regions (MISO, CAISO, SPP, PJM, ERCOT); solar + storage only in two. ⚠ Grid lines and transmission are extra in every row.
SourcePlant aloneWith backup (“firmed”)
Wind, onshore$37–$86$81–$138
Solar, utility-scale$38–$78$89–$142
Solar + battery storage$50–$131$142–$164
Gas, combined cycle$48–$109— (runs on demand)
Nuclear, new build$141–$220— (runs steadily)

Lazard LCOE+ v18, June 2025 (plant costs p. 8; firming results p. 30) · Reuters, June 16, 2025. Pen: Lazard, an investment bank that advises energy deals. Paid: Lazard’s own research. Lazard notes its firmed figure is not the cost of a single plant running 24/7.

U.S. Energy Information Administration · August 2023

Federal energy subsidies, fiscal 2016–2022: $183 billion. Renewables took 46% — and their yearly share grew from $7.4 billion (2016) to $15.6 billion (2022).

EIA, Federal Financial Interventions and Subsidies in Energy

Pen
EIA statisticians, at Congress’s request.
Paid
Taxpayers. The count leaves out state programs and many fossil-fuel tax rules that critics call subsidies.

International Energy Agency · May 2021

Before any of it makes power, an onshore wind plant needs nine times the minerals of a gas plant — mined, crushed and refined with energy.

IEA, Critical Minerals report

Pen
IEA analysts.
Paid
IEA member governments.

Is that a scam, or not?

  • One chart rewards nuclear; the other rewards wind and solar. Which question were you shown first — and which one was left out?
  • When the cheapest-looking power needs backup to be there at night, is the backup on the price tag you saw?
  • If the subsidy grows while the cost “falls,” which number is the real price?
  • That one stays open. The numbers are here; the answer is yours.
06

Carbon credits

What exactly is
a carbon credit?

One credit is meant to stand for one tonne of CO₂ kept out of the air or pulled from it — measured against a guess of what would have happened without the project. Nobody can weigh a tonne that was never emitted. So who does the counting?

Science · July 2025

Who checks the tonne? In most programs, the project developer picks and pays the auditor. Two law scholars found 21 of 33 auditors approved by the biggest registry had signed off on projects later shown to over-claim.

Coglianese & Giles, “Auditors can’t save carbon offsets” · Penn Law summary

Pen
Cary Coglianese (University of Pennsylvania) and Cynthia Giles, a former EPA enforcement chief.
Paid
The audits: the sellers. ⚠ The authors’ funding not checked here.

January 18, 2023

A newspaper analysis said more than 90% of rainforest offsets from the biggest certifier were likely “phantom credits.” The certifier, Verra, called that analysis “patently unreliable.”

The Guardian, with Die Zeit and SourceMaterial · Verra’s response

Pen
Journalists, using academic studies; and the certifier answering.
Paid
Companies buying offsets — the article names Disney, Shell and Gucci among buyers.

SDNY & CFTC · October 2, 2024

A former CEO of carbon-credit developer C-Quest Capital was charged with fraud over cookstove credits. These are allegations. The former COO pleaded guilty; the company was not charged after it self-reported.

CFTC release 8994-24 · Indictment, U.S. v. Newcombe et al.

Pen
Federal prosecutors and the CFTC.
Paid
Taxpayers. Charged people are presumed innocent unless convicted.

World Bank · May 21, 2024

Carbon taxes and emissions trading — the government side of carbon pricing — raised a record $104 billion in 2023.

World Bank, State and Trends of Carbon Pricing 2024

Pen
World Bank staff.
Paid
Businesses and, through prices, the people who buy from them.

Sit with it

  • When you buy a credit, what do you actually own — a tonne, or a promise about a tonne?
  • If the seller pays the person who checks the seller, who is the check for?
  • If the buyer, the seller and the certifier all gain when a credit counts, who is left to ask?
  • Where does the $104 billion go after it is collected?
07

Greta, then and now

She said “How dare you.”
What does she say now?

The record: her own words, with dates

UN Climate Action Summit, New York · September 23, 2019 · age 16

“This is all wrong. I shouldn’t be up here. I should be back in school on the other side of the ocean. Yet you all come to us young people for hope. How dare you! You have stolen my dreams and my childhood with your empty words.”

NPR, full transcript

Pen
Greta Thunberg. The stage: the UN Secretary-General’s summit.
Paid
The summit: the UN, funded by member states. ⚠ Her travel and support costs not checked here.

Gaza flotillas · June & October 2025

Twice she sailed with aid flotillas toward Gaza. In October 2025 Israeli forces intercepted the boats; she was among 171 activists deported on October 6. She alleged mistreatment in detention; Israel denied it.

Reuters, Oct 6, 2025 · Reuters, Oct 7, 2025

Pen
Reuters, quoting her and Israeli officials.
Paid
⚠ Flotilla funding not checked here.

London · December 23, 2025

Arrested under the Terrorism Act for holding a sign: “I support the Palestine Action prisoners. I oppose genocide.” Released on bail. An arrest is an allegation, not a conviction.

BBC · Reuters, Dec 23, 2025

Pen
London police; reporters.
Paid
Taxpayers. ⚠ Outcome of the case not checked here.

COP31, Antalya, Türkiye · November 10–12, 2026 · age 23

“COPs have become greenwashed circuses. That is the reality.” Two days later: the planet is “not dying, it is being killed and we know by who.”

CNA/AFP, Nov 10, 2026 · The Guardian, Nov 12, 2026

Pen
Greta Thunberg, to the press.
Paid
The summit: host Türkiye and UN member states.

⚠ A circulating clip · what the record shows, and what it doesn’t

Documentary released October 28, 2026 · viral November 2026

Told that a Fridays for Future march was happening in Berlin that day, she laughs: “Really? They still do that?” Then: “Cut.”

Her explanation: it was the same day her group was blocking a weapons maker, and the march was by “the very same German climate movement who cancelled and ‘distanced themselves’ from me” over her Gaza statements. The filmmaker, Hubertus Koch: the clip was “taken out of context”; she had come to see permitted marches as ineffective.

Der Spiegel, Nov 12, 2026 · 20 Minuten · VT, Nov 14, 2026, quoting her Instagram

Pen
Koch’s film “Auf Panzern in die Klimakrise” (YouTube); her own post.
Paid
⚠ Film funding not checked. ⚠ What she meant by the laugh: only she can say. The clip is real; the captions online are interpretation.

Sit with it

  • At 16 she asked the adults, “How dare you.” At 23 she calls the summits “circuses.” Who changed — her, the summits, or both?
  • When a movement’s face moves to a new cause, does the old cause lose its voice, or gain a new one?
  • When a short clip goes around the world, who watches the rest of the film?
08

Science vs. common sense

When did questions
become heresy?

A president’s warning · January 17, 1961

“Yet, in holding scientific research and discovery in respect, as we should, we must also be alert to the equal and opposite danger that public policy could itself become the captive of a scientific-technological elite.”
Dwight D. Eisenhower, farewell address. National Archives.

A Nobel physicist to science teachers · 1966

“Science is the belief in the ignorance of experts.”
Richard Feynman, “What Is Science?”, National Science Teachers Association; printed in The Physics Teacher, 1969. Source notes.

The record

“97%” · Environmental Research Letters, May 2013

Of 11,944 paper abstracts, 66.4% took no position on human-caused warming. Of the 4,014 that did, 97.1% endorsed it. That is the “97%.”

A critique, 2015: counting only abstracts that said humans caused most warming, the paper’s own data gave 41 — about 0.3%. The authors’ position (paraphrased): most abstracts don’t restate settled points, so “no position” is not doubt.

Cook et al., 2013 · Legates et al., Science & Education, 2015

Pen
Cook’s team ran Skeptical Science, a pro-consensus website; Legates’ team includes consensus critics.
Paid
⚠ Neither team’s funding checked here.

Georgia Tech · January 3, 2017

Climate scientist Judith Curry resigned her tenured post, citing “my growing disenchantment with universities, the academic field of climate science and scientists.” For young skeptics, she wrote, “it often becomes a battle of scientific integrity versus career suicide.”

Her post, “JC in transition”

Pen
Herself. She said she also wanted time for her forecasting company.
Paid
Her company’s clients, afterward.

High Court of Australia · October 13, 2021

Physicist Peter Ridd was fired by James Cook University after publicly questioning reef science. The High Court upheld the firing, unanimously.

The court’s reason: his contract protected intellectual freedom, but he was dismissed for breaching confidentiality and conduct rules — not, it said, for his views. His side: the case was about academic freedom.

Ridd v James Cook University [2021] HCA 32 · ABC News

Pen
The High Court, unanimously.
Paid
The university and Ridd. ⚠ His legal-fund donors not checked here.

The Free Press · September 5, 2023

Climate scientist Patrick Brown on his own wildfire paper in Nature: “I left out the full truth to get my climate change paper published.”

Nature’s answer: editor Magdalena Skipper said his choices reflected “poor research practices” and that the journal has no preferred narrative.

The Free Press · Phys.org, with Nature’s response

Pen
Brown himself; the journal answering.
Paid
⚠ Study funding not checked here.

The Lancet Planetary Health · December 2021

A survey of 10,000 people aged 16–25 in ten countries: 59% very or extremely worried about climate change; 75% said “the future is frightening.”

Hickman et al., 2021

Pen
University psychologists in the UK, U.S. and Finland.
Paid
Avaaz, a campaign group, paid for the survey; it said it had no role in the analysis or writing.

Sit with it

  • When “the science” is said in the singular, whose science is it?
  • If a young person is taught to fear before being taught to measure, is that education — or something else?
  • Is trust in experts the same as faith? When does one become the other?
  • If the farmer’s eyes and the model disagree, who should check whom?
09

Who else is in it?

Follow the faces.
Follow the funds.

A web of documented links: who paid whom, who passed which law, who flew where. Each line is a record. What the lines add up to — a movement, a market, a mix of both? You decide.

Swipe sideways to see the whole chart →

NewsroomsAP · Covering Climate NowFoundations & billionairesBloomberg · Bezos · Gates · RockefellerGovernments & UNUNFCCC · IPCC · EPAActivist groupsJust Stop Oil · A22Famous facesGore · Kerry · DiCaprio · SwiftForumsWEF Davos · COPIndustrysolar · wind · EVsBanks & fundsnet-zero alliancesAgencies & dev banksWorld Bank · IEA · UNEPCarbon marketsregistries · auditors$8M → AP climate desk (2022)$1.1M via CEF → Just Stop Oil (2022)Bloomberg pays U.S. UNFCCC share (2025)tax credits (2022 law)developers pay auditorsWorld Bank: 48% ‘climate’ (FY25)UN-convened NZBA, 2021–25COP26: 11 corporate partnersjets to Davos (2022)
⚠ A line is a dated payment, law, membership or flight, sourced below. It is not evidence that anyone coordinated or intended anything.

Faces — in their own words and records

Al Gore

Former U.S. vice president; film-maker; investor

Oct 12, 2007 · 2004 → today

Shared the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize with the IPCC. In 2004 he co-founded Generation Investment Management, a “sustainable investing” firm, with David Blood; it reports about $22.6 billion under management. His seaside home is in the Seas section.

His side: ⚠ A direct answer from him on the overlap of advocacy and investing was not gathered in this search.

Nobel Prize, 2007 · Generation IM, firm site

Pen
The Nobel Committee; the firm’s own figures.
Paid
The firm: its clients’ fees. ⚠ Fee terms are private.

John Kerry

First U.S. Special Presidential Envoy for Climate

Jan 2021 – Mar 2024

Led U.S. climate diplomacy at COP26, COP27 and COP28. His 2019 private-jet answer — “the only choice for somebody like me” — is in the Seas section.

His side: his office said he “travels commercially” as envoy; the family jet was sold in August 2022.

State Dept. biography · Washington Examiner, Feb 15, 2023

Pen
The State Department; his spokeswoman.
Paid
Taxpayers (the post).

Bill Gates

Microsoft co-founder; Breakthrough Energy founder

February 7, 2023 · Kenya

Asked by the BBC about his private jet: “not only am I not part of the problem by paying for the offsets, but also through the billions that my Breakthrough Energy Group is spending, that I’m part of the solution.” Breakthrough Energy Ventures has more than $3.5 billion committed, with investors including Jeff Bezos and Michael Bloomberg.

His side: the quote above is his own answer.

CNBC, Feb 7, 2023 · Breakthrough Energy

Pen
BBC interview; the fund’s own site.
Paid
Gates and co-investors — who also stand to profit if the bets pay off. ⚠ Whether profit shapes the advocacy is a question, not a finding.

Jeff Bezos

Amazon founder; Bezos Earth Fund

February 17, 2020

Pledged $10 billion to start the Bezos Earth Fund: “This global initiative will fund scientists, activists, NGOs — any effort that offers a real possibility to help preserve and protect the natural world.”

His side: the pledge is his own statement. ⚠ His travel and homes were not reviewed here.

Bezos, Instagram, Feb 17, 2020

Pen
Bezos.
Paid
Bezos, as a pledge.

Michael Bloomberg

Bloomberg Philanthropies; UN Special Envoy on Climate Ambition and Solutions

June 7, 2019 · January 23, 2025

Committed $500 million to Beyond Carbon, a campaign to close U.S. coal plants. After the U.S. left the Paris Agreement again, said his foundation would cover the U.S. share of the UN climate body’s budget (amount not disclosed).

His side: he frames it as filling a gap left by Washington.

Earthjustice, June 7, 2019 · Reuters, Jan 23, 2025

Pen
His foundation; Reuters.
Paid
Bloomberg’s fortune.

Leonardo DiCaprio

Actor; foundation founder; UN Messenger of Peace (climate)

Feb 28, 2016 · May 2016

Oscar speech: “Climate change is real. It is happening right now. It is the most urgent threat facing our entire species.” Weeks later, the Telegraph reported he took a private jet from Cannes to New York to collect an environmental award, then flew back.

His side: ⚠ No direct response from him was found in this search; who paid for and shared those flights is not shown here.

Oscars speech database · The Telegraph, May 21, 2016

Pen
The Academy transcript; British press.
Paid
The award: Riverkeeper. The flights: ⚠ not shown.

Prince Harry

Duke of Sussex; Travalyst co-founder

September 3, 2019 · Amsterdam

Launching a green-travel project after summer private-jet flights: “I spend 99% of my life travelling the world by commercial.” The private flights were “to ensure that my family is safe,” and the emissions were offset.

His side: the quotes above are his own answer.

USA Today, Sept 3, 2019

Pen
His launch remarks.
Paid
⚠ Who paid for the flights was not confirmed in this search.

Taylor Swift

Singer

July–August 2022

Topped a marketing firm’s 2022 celebrity-jet emissions estimate (details in the Seas section).

Her side: the jet “is loaned out regularly”; pinning the trips on her is “blatantly incorrect.”

The Guardian, Aug 2, 2022

Pen
Yard, a UK marketing agency.
Paid
Yard.

Barack Obama

Former U.S. president

June 3, 2008 · Dec 4, 2019

Promised the moment “the rise of the oceans began to slow”; in 2019 his family trust bought a waterfront estate (Seas section).

His side: ⚠ not found in this search.

Vineyard Gazette, Dec 4, 2019

Pen
His speech; the deed registry.
Paid
The buyer’s trust.

Agencies — what they set in motion

UN climate body (UNFCCC)

The treaty body that runs the yearly COP summits

Baku · November 24, 2024

COP29 set a goal of at least $300 billion a year by 2035 from richer to poorer nations, and called for $1.3 trillion a year from all sources.

Its side: ⚠ Not gathered in this search.

UNFCCC, Nov 24, 2024

Pen
UN negotiators from about 200 governments.
Paid
Member states’ dues — and, since 2025, Bloomberg for the U.S. share.

IPCC

UN science panel

Created 1988 · AR6 August 9, 2021

Set up by the WMO and UNEP to assess research, not to run it. Its 2021 report: human influence on warming is “unequivocal.” Each summary is approved line by line by government delegates.

Its side: the panel calls its work “policy-relevant and yet policy-neutral, never policy-prescriptive.”

IPCC, About · AR6 WG1

Pen
Volunteer authors; government reviewers.
Paid
The IPCC Trust Fund: government contributions.

UNEP

UN Environment Programme

1988 · June 1989

Co-founded the IPCC. In 1989 a UNEP official warned whole nations could be “wiped off the face of the Earth” by 2000 (see Deadlines).

Its side: ⚠ No later UNEP comment on that 1989 remark was found.

UNEP, About · AP, June 29, 1989

Pen
UN staff.
Paid
UN member states’ contributions.

World Economic Forum

Host of the yearly Davos meeting

Davos · 2022 · January 10, 2024

Its 2024 Global Risks Report ranked extreme weather the top risk over ten years. In 2022, 1,040 private-jet flights served Davos week (Seas section).

Its side: ⚠ A WEF response to the jet count was not found in this search.

WEF Global Risks Report 2024

Pen
WEF staff and a survey of its members.
Paid
Member and partner companies’ fees.

U.S. EPA

Federal regulator

Dec 7, 2009 → Feb 12, 2026

Its 2009 “endangerment finding” said greenhouse gases endanger public health and became the base for U.S. climate rules. The EPA moved to rescind it in July 2025 and finalized that in February 2026, effective April 20, 2026. Lawsuits over the repeal are under way.

Both sides (paraphrased): the EPA now says the law did not grant that power; challengers say the science and the law require it.

EPA · Federal Register, Feb 18, 2026

Pen
Two administrations’ EPA staff.
Paid
Taxpayers.

World Bank Group

Development lender

Fiscal 2025

Said 48% of its fiscal-2025 financing carried “climate co-benefits,” above its 45% target.

⚠ “Co-benefits” are counted under the bank’s own method.

World Bank, climate

Pen
Bank staff, under its own counting rules.
Paid
Shareholder governments; bond buyers.

International Energy Agency

Energy adviser to member governments

May 18, 2021

Its “Net Zero by 2050” roadmap: beyond projects already committed, “no new oil and gas fields approved for development.”

Its side: a path, not a forecast. ⚠ Critics’ replies not gathered here.

IEA, Net Zero by 2050

Pen
IEA analysts.
Paid
Member governments.

Banks, newsrooms, activists

Banks

Net-Zero Banking Alliance (UN-convened, 2021)

Dec 2024 – Oct 3, 2025

Goldman Sachs, Wells Fargo, Citi, Bank of America, Morgan Stanley and JPMorgan left in Dec 2024–Jan 2025. The alliance stopped operating on October 3, 2025. Its asset-manager twin paused after BlackRock left in January 2025 and relaunched in February 2026 with 250+ members.

Their side: several banks said they would keep their own climate goals.

Reuters, Oct 3, 2025

Pen
Reuters.
Paid
Member fees; the banks.

Newsrooms

The Associated Press · Covering Climate Now

February 15, 2022

The AP took more than $8 million from five foundations — Rockefeller, Hewlett, Walton, Quadrivium and HHMI — to build a climate team of 20-plus journalists. Covering Climate Now, started in 2019 by the Columbia Journalism Review and The Nation, counts 500+ partner outlets.

Their side: the AP says it keeps full editorial control.

Axios, Feb 15, 2022 · Covering Climate Now

Pen
The AP; Axios.
Paid
The five foundations. ⚠ Whether money shapes coverage is a question, not a finding.

Activist funding

Climate Emergency Fund

2019 → October 2022

Set up in 2019; heir Aileen Getty gave $1 million and film-maker Adam McKay pledged $4 million. It gave Just Stop Oil about $1.1 million in 2022.

Their side: Getty: “I do not fund these groups directly.” The fund: “All activities we fund are fully legal.”

Getty, The Guardian, Oct 22, 2022 · CEF

Pen
The Guardian; the fund.
Paid
Its donors.

Sit with it

  • When the same names fund the research, the reporting and the protest, who is left to ask the hard questions? ⚠
  • If believers fly private and buy on the shore, is that hypocrisy — or just wealth? ⚠ Only they can say.
  • When did a question about the science start to feel like a test of faith?
10

Sponsors & the climate economy

How much money
rides on the answer?

Big numbers, each with its source and year. Some are yearly spending, one is a pile of savings, one is a ten-year cost. They overlap — so they cannot be added into one total. Who gains if the answer stays the same? Who loses if it changes?

Swipe sideways to see the whole chart →

$0$1T$2T$3T$4TSustainable fund assetsstock of savings, end-2025 · Morningstar$3.9TClean-energy investmentper year, 2025 est. · IEA$2.2TClimate finance trackedin 2023 · CPI$1.9TFossil-fuel investment (for scale)per year, 2025 est. · IEA$1.1TU.S. IRA energy provisionsover ~10 years · CBO 2022 / CRFB 2024$391B–$870BUN goal for rich → poor nationsper year by 2035 · COP29$300BCarbon taxes & permit salesin 2023 · World Bank$104BU.S. federal subsidies to renewablesFY2022 · EIA$15.6BClimate philanthropyin 2024 · ClimateWorks$11.7B–$18.4B⚠ Do not add these up: they overlap and measure different things (stocks vs. yearly flows vs. 10-year costs). Light bars = range of estimates.
Sources: Morningstar, Q4 2025 · IEA, June 5, 2025 · CPI, June 2025 · CRFB, 2024 · UNFCCC, Nov 24, 2024 · World Bank, May 21, 2024 · EIA, Aug 2023 · ClimateWorks.
⚠ Overlaps: CPI’s climate finance includes much of the IEA’s clean-energy spending; U.S. IRA-backed projects likely sit inside both; fund assets are savings, not spending; the UN goal is a pledge, not money paid.

The sponsors — dated amounts

Bezos Earth Fund

February 17, 2020

$10 billion pledged “to start,” for “scientists, activists, NGOs.”

Bezos, Instagram

Pen
Bezos.
Paid
Bezos. ⚠ Grants paid out so far not tallied here.

Bloomberg Philanthropies

June 7, 2019 · Jan 23, 2025

$500 million for Beyond Carbon, aimed at closing coal plants and blocking new gas plants; later, the U.S. share of the UN climate body’s budget (amount not disclosed).

MIT, June 2019 · Reuters, Jan 23, 2025

Pen
Bloomberg’s announcements.
Paid
Michael Bloomberg.

Gates · Breakthrough Energy

2016 → today

Breakthrough Energy Ventures: more than $3.5 billion committed to clean-tech start-ups; backers include Bezos and Bloomberg.

His side: “the billions … I’m part of the solution.” (CNBC, Feb 7, 2023)

Breakthrough Energy · CNBC

Pen
The fund.
Paid
⚠ An investment, not a gift: investors expect returns.

Hewlett · Packard · McKnight

2008

Launched the ClimateWorks Foundation with more than $1.1 billion pledged over the following years; Hewlett’s share was $500 million over five years.

Hewlett Foundation · Chronicle of Philanthropy, 2008

Pen
The foundations.
Paid
Their endowments.

Rockefeller · Hewlett · Walton · Quadrivium · HHMI

February 15, 2022

More than $8 million to the Associated Press for a climate news team.

AP’s side: it keeps full editorial control.

Axios

Pen
The AP; Axios.
Paid
The five foundations.

Getty · McKay · Climate Emergency Fund

2019 → 2022

Aileen Getty gave $1 million and Adam McKay pledged $4 million to the fund, which gave Just Stop Oil about $1.1 million in 2022.

Their side: Getty: “I do not fund these groups directly.”

The Guardian, Oct 22, 2022

Pen
The Guardian; the fund.
Paid
Its donors.

Corporate COP26 partners

Nov 2020 – 2021

The UK named 11 Principal Partners for the Glasgow summit: SSE, ScottishPower, NatWest, National Grid, Sky, Sainsbury’s, Hitachi, Reckitt, GSK, Microsoft and Unilever.

⚠ Their payments were not disclosed in these releases.

GOV.UK, Nov 2020

Pen
The UK government.
Paid
The companies — several of which sell energy or green products.

All givers together

2024

Foundations and individuals gave an estimated $11.7–$18.4 billion to cutting emissions in 2024 — about 2.1% of all giving. Foundations alone: $6 billion.

ClimateWorks, Funding Trends 2026

Pen
ClimateWorks — itself a climate funder.
Paid
Its funders.

Ford Foundation · Open Society

—

⚠ Both are often named as climate funders. Their climate totals were not gathered in this search, so no figure is shown.

—

Pen
Not checked.
Paid
Not checked.

Sit with it

  • Trillions a year now ride on one answer. Would you expect the people paid by that answer to question it? ⚠
  • Does money prove a claim wrong — or only tell you to check it twice?
  • If the science changed tomorrow, who would lose the most?
11

The report pen

Scientists draft it.
Governments approve it, line by line.

IPCC procedures · adopted 1999, amended since

The Summary for Policymakers is “approved” — meaning “detailed, line by line discussion and agreement” at a session of government delegates, with the authors in the room.

IPCC Principles, Appendix A · IPCC fact sheet, April 2024

Pen
Working Group Co-Chairs draft; member governments approve the wording.
Paid
IPCC Trust Fund: member governments, WMO, UNEP, UNFCCC.

IPCC AR6 Synthesis · March 20, 2023

The headline line governments approved: human activities “have unequivocally caused global warming.”

IPCC AR6 Synthesis Report, SPM statement A.1

Pen
Core writing team; summary approved line by line by government delegates at the Panel’s 58th session in Interlaken, Switzerland, on March 19, 2023 (IPCC).
Paid
Member governments, through the Trust Fund and in-kind support.

Sit with it

  • When a government approves a scientific summary, whose sentence is it?
  • Who reads the full report, and who only reads the summary?
  • Would a summary approved by the same governments that set policy look different if someone else held the pen?
12

The money pens

Money flows on
every side.

February 17, 2020

Jeff Bezos announced the Bezos Earth Fund, $10 billion to start: “This global initiative will fund scientists, activists, NGOs — any effort that offers a real possibility to help preserve and protect the natural world.”

NPR, Feb 17, 2020 · BBC

Pen
Bezos, in his own Instagram post.
Paid
Bezos, as a pledge. Which groups got grants is a separate record, not checked here.

January 2007

A watchdog report counted nearly $16 million from ExxonMobil, 1998–2005, to 43 groups that raised doubt about climate science.

Union of Concerned Scientists, “Smoke, Mirrors & Hot Air”

Pen
Union of Concerned Scientists, an advocacy group.
Paid
UCS members and donors. ⚠ Its word “disinformation” is its framing, not a court finding.

New York Supreme Court · December 10, 2019

The other side of the ledger: New York’s fraud case against ExxonMobil lost at trial. The judge found the state did not prove investors were misled.

People v. Exxon Mobil Corp., opinion of Justice Barry Ostrager

Pen
The court.
Paid
Taxpayers for the state’s case; Exxon for its defense. The opinion also said nothing in it absolves ExxonMobil of responsibility for contributing to climate change through emissions.

Sit with it

  • Is a billionaire’s climate grant a different kind of pen than an oil company’s grant?
  • When one side’s money is called “funding” and the other’s is called “influence,” who chose the words?
  • ⚠ Is there one plan behind the money, or many interests pulling in different directions? Nothing here shows a single plan.
13

Subsidies & ESG

Same law.
Changing price tag.

CBO · August 2022

When the Inflation Reduction Act passed (August 16, 2022), its energy and climate provisions were scored at about $391 billion over ten years.

CRFB summary of the CBO score, Sept 7, 2022

Pen
Congressional Budget Office and Joint Committee on Taxation.
Paid
Taxpayers, through tax credits.

February 13, 2024

A fiscal watchdog’s reading of later CBO numbers: about $660 billion through 2031 — and nearly $870 billion with a new vehicle rule.

Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget

Pen
CRFB analysts.
Paid
CRFB donors. ⚠ Not checked here. Other groups give higher and lower figures.

SEC · September 25, 2023

An agency finding: Deutsche Bank’s DWS made “materially misleading statements” about its ESG process and paid a $19 million penalty, without admitting or denying.

SEC press release 2023-194 · SEC order

Pen
The SEC.
Paid
DWS paid the penalty; its fund investors had paid for the “ESG” label.

Sit with it

  • When a price tag can grow after a law passes, who was told the first number?
  • Who earns the credits — farmers and families, or the largest firms that can file for them?
  • If “green” can be a label on a fund, who checks the label?
14

Voices outside the record

In their
own words.

Testimony and opinion · not findings

A climate scientist · U.S. Senate · December 8, 2015

“There is enormous pressure for climate scientists to conform to the so-called consensus… Reinforcing this consensus are strong monetary, reputational, and authority interests.”
Judith A. Curry, then Georgia Tech, written testimony to the Senate Space, Science and Competitiveness subcommittee, “Data or Dogma?” Testimony PDF. Pen: herself. She disclosed she also ran a climate-forecast company.

A Nobel physicist · May 5, 2023

“In my opinion, there is no real climate crisis. There is, however, a very real problem with providing a decent standard of living to the world’s large population and an associated energy crisis.”
John F. Clauser, 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, in the CO2 Coalition’s announcement of his election to its board, May 5, 2023. CO2 Coalition release (PDF). Pen: the CO2 Coalition, which campaigns on this view, quoting him. ⚠ Funding of the CO2 Coalition not checked here. His Nobel is in quantum physics, not climate science; critics raise that.

A farmer · New Zealand · October 20, 2022

“If you just charge willy nilly for something that you actually have no solution to, then it’s a tax.”
Bryce McKenzie, co-founder of Groundswell NZ, on a plan to price farm emissions, as tractors rolled into city centres. RNZ. Signs read “more regulations = less food.”

Everyday people · France · November 2018

“The elites talk about the end of the world, while we talk about the end of the month.”
A Yellow Vest slogan during protests over a fuel-tax rise tied to climate goals, as reported by France 24, Nov 27, 2018. A crowd slogan; no single author. ⚠ Wording varies by translation.

The other side, in its own words

The IPCC · March 20, 2023

“Human activities, principally through emissions of greenhouse gases, have unequivocally caused global warming.”
AR6 Synthesis Report, SPM A.1. IPCC. Pen: authors, approved by governments. Paid: governments.

A prime minister answers the farmers · October 20, 2022

“My focus is on working constructively with our food producers to get the best possible outcome for them and for New Zealand.”
Jacinda Ardern, the same day, same RNZ report. She said the plan started from a system the farm sector itself proposed.

Sit with it

  • Who gets called a “scientist,” and who gets called a “denier” — and who decides?
  • Was the farmer in the room when the farm rule was written?
  • Testimonies from people who lived it can be added later. This site has no form and collects no personal information.

Who held the pen?
Who paid?
You decide.

A question, not a verdict. Every card above links to its source. Read them. Ask who wrote each one.

Still open

  • When a deadline passes, who is asked to account for it?
  • When the panel, the credit and the subsidy all come from the same push, who is paid to doubt it?
  • Can the same body write the science, approve the summary and set the policy — and still be checked?
  • When a market is built on a number no buyer can see, who audits the number?
  • If a farmer, a physicist and a panel of governments all say “follow the science,” whose science gets the microphone?

Coming to these pages